12/20/1896 to 2/12/1898 – Reverend George Julius Sick
3/1/1898 to 9/3/1905 – Reverend Frantz Peter Gotke
2/1/1906 to 4/11/1909 – Reverend Michael Fredik Blichfeld
11/13/1921 to 2/28/1937 – Reverend Viggo Marinus Hansen
6/1/1937 to 9/7/1942 – Reverend Jens Christian Kjaer – KIA – WWII
2/7/1943 to 2/1/1948 – Reverend Edwin Enrico Hansen
5/31/1948 to 10/18/1953 – Reverend Robert C. Schmidt
10/25/1953 to 9/1/1976 – Reverend Robert S. Heide
1/1/1977 to 1/17/1993 – Reverend Jerome Allen Bengtson
1/31/1993 to 10/15/1994 – Reverend Robert R. Schuerman (interim)
10/16/1994 to 9/19/1999 – Dr. Karl A. Otto
11/01/1999 – 11/11/2001 – Rev Sue Bowen (Term)
11/11/2001 – 6/16/2002 – Reverend Mike Ziolnosky (interim)
6/16/2002 – 2007 – Reverend Paul Van De Berg
1/7/2008 – 6/06/2010 – Reverend Steve Wohlfeil
6/13/2010 – 10/24/2010 – various supply pastors
10/30/2010 – 11/14/2011 – Reverend Pam Lange (term)
1/27/2013 – 5/9/2021 – Reverend Heather Bumstead (Contract)
11/1/2021 – 11/30/22 – Reverend Allison Johnson (Contract)
12/01/22 – 1/28/2024 – various supply pastors
1/29/2024 – Present – Reverend Paul Nuechterlein (PACT)